HCPLive Network

Despite Its Popularity, Plastic Surgery Has a Bad Reputation

You wouldn’t know that America was in an economic recession by the number of cosmetic procedures that took place in 2012. According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, there were more than 14.6 million cosmetic procedures performed last year, of which nearly 6.1 million were Botox (onabotulinumtoxinA) treatments.

But despite its mainstream popularity, cosmetic surgery still has a very negative stigma in our culture. In fact, a 2011 University of Toronto study that found women who had received Botox treatments were typically viewed by their peers as “cold and vain” compared to those who appeared to have aged naturally.

The study examined how women viewed other women’s personalities based upon the anti-aging techniques they utilized. Study participants read fictional stories about middle-aged to senior women who underwent various anti-aging techniques that ranged from avoiding the sun and using skin creams, to receiving Botox injections and undergoing facelifts. Participants were then asked to rate how they perceived the characters, and the findings were surprising. According to an article published in the New York Daily News, “The results showed that the less a woman tried to interfere with aging naturally, the more positively her personality was viewed by the participants in the study.”

But is this a fair judgment? Women are expected to be naturally thin and appear effortlessly young, but when they take additional measures to maintain or enhance their looks, they are heavily criticized. Meanwhile, a good number of the Hollywood celebrities who women are trying to emulate have also incorporated cosmetic procedures into their beauty regimens, but in an unperceivable and subtle way.

The results of the University of Toronto study are even more surprising in light of the number of female celebrities who have admitted to surgical and non-surgical procedures. In a November 2008 People Magazine article, many female celebrities — including Brooke Shields, Jenny McCarthy, Vanessa Williams, and Courtney Cox — stepped forward and openly admitted to benefiting from Botox treatments. However, they stressed that, as all things in life, moderation is always the key; it’s about finding a balance to compliment your true beauty. As Vanessa Williams was quoted in the article, “I use it very sparingly…I want to look natural.”

These principals fall in line with my own theory known as the Life Stage Personal Enhancement Philosophy. Instead of a full body makeover all at once, smaller, less-invasive, and age-appropriate procedures done over a longer period of time can maintain a person’s youthful appearance – further eliminating that surgical or unnatural look.

Robert T. Grant, MD, MSc, FACS, is Chief of the combined Divisions of Plastic Surgery at New York-Presbyterian Hospital-Columbia University Medical Center and New York-Presbyterian Hospital-Weill Cornell Medical Center. He is also Associate Clinical Professor of Surgery in the College of Physicians and Surgeons at Columbia University and Adjunct Associate Professor of Clinical Surgery at Weill Cornell Medical College. For more information about Dr. Grant or to contact him, visit his website at www.robertgrantmd.com.
Further Reading
When these physicians attend sporting events, then watch the game in a different way than the average fan.
As the days of the file folders crammed with patient information passes, the question becomes what doctors’ offices will look like in the digital age.
Risk factors associated with severity of the disease may help guide therapy for hidradenitis suppurativa, according to research published in the September issue of the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology.
Inclusion of endogenous hormones in prediction models improves prediction of invasive breast cancer risk in postmenopausal women, according to a study published online Aug. 18 in the Journal of Clinical Oncology.
A noninvasive, abdominal acoustic monitoring device can distinguish postoperative ileus (POI) from patients and controls without POI, according to a proof-of-concept study published online Aug. 5 in the Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.
Sunscreen use has decreased among adolescents, and a considerable proportion use indoor tanning devices, according to research published online Aug. 21 in the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Preventing Chronic Disease.
Documentation rules for annual wellness visits for Medicare differ from those for preventive visits, which are not covered by Medicare, according to an article published Aug. 5 in Medical Economics.
More Reading