HCPLive Network

Patients in Study Feel Physicians Informed Consent Explanations Lacking

A great deal of research has been published over the years regarding informed consent, and although more empirical research has been published, there is very little information available on how the consent process actually works in clinical practice.

Australian researchers, however, recently investigated informed consent disputes in a large sample of medical negligence claims and health care complaints that were resolved over a seven-year period. They found that in 71% of cases, the primary allegation was that the physician, most often a surgeon, failed to mention or properly explain risks of complications.

“This is the first study to investigate, in a real-world setting, what happens when informed consent goes poorly from the patient’s perspective,” David Studdert, a professor at the Melbourne School of Population Health and Melbourne Law School, said in a statement. The research was published in a recent issue of the Medical Journal of Australia.

Studdert and his co-authors reviewed nearly 2,000 negligence claims against doctors insured by Avant Mutual Group Limited and complaints lodged with the Health Services Commissioner of Victoria between January 2002 and December 2008.

Of those cases, more than 92% involved surgical procedures and 16% involved cosmetic procedures. The researchers found that patients’ concerns about problems in the informed consent process were matched by concerns about other aspects of care in about half the cases.

Five treatment types accounted for almost 50% of the total cases. These were surgical procedures on reproductive organs (12%), the face (12%), breast (7%), and the eyes (7%), and the side effects of prescription medications (8%). The research showed that plastic surgeons experienced complaint rates that were more than twice those of any other specialty or subspecialty group.

“In my experience, most doctors feel that they adequately discuss the risks of a procedure as part of their practice. Our findings show that our patients do not always share this view,” lead author Andrew Gogos, MD, neurosurgical registrar at the Royal North Shore Hospital in Sydney, said in a statement. Gogos added that the main problem was communication.

“The typical dispute over informed consent involves an operation and relates to the adequacy of explanations about risks of a particular complication. The complication may be anything from the risk of infection, pain or scarring, paralysis, even death.” Gogos said.

“With cosmetic surgery, patients are typically healthy going into the procedure and their expectations of a positive outcome tend to be very high. This causes them to worry about even small risks.”

Studdert said improved understanding of these situations would help highlight areas where there is a gap between what doctors talk about and what patients want to hear. “Much more can be learned about how to improve medical care from close analysis of disputes over preventable events,” he said.

Sources
Patient Complaints Allege Doctors Fail to Disclose Risks [University of Melbourne]
When Informed Consent Goes Poorly: A Descriptive Study of Medical Negligence Claims and Patient Complaints [Medical Journal of Australia]



Further Reading
Advances in treatment could provide much needed help for patients with obesity, diabetes, and hypertension
Surgical simulation is becoming an increasingly important educational tool and performance metric in the training of orthopedic surgeons. Understanding and visualizing a surgical procedure before executing it in practice is crucial to surgical training success.
For patients diagnosed with osteoarthritis, daily activities that many people take for granted, including sleep, can be interrupted or difficult, often causing psychological challenges as well.
Most Americans know that a given medical service could cost a significantly different amount depending on where one receives the service, but only recently have cost data about healthcare charges become widely available and widely discussed. National Nurses United earlier this year evaluated US hospitals to find out how much they charge for a procedure versus the actual cost of performing the procedure.
The use of bone morphogenetic protein is not associated with operative nonunion rates after spinal fusion, according to a study published in the Oct. 15 issue of Spine.
A learning model and discussion can improve residents' attitudes and communication skills towards patients with substance abuse disorders, according to a study published online Oct. 7 in Academic Medicine.
The fact that cigarette smoking is dangerous to a person’s health is not a new concept, but a recent study took a more direct view of just how much damage smokers in the United States do to themselves through what was described as “major medical conditions.”
More Reading