Article

"One Cannot Measure What One Does Not Manage": Socialized Medicine, Unaffordable? (Part XIII-o)

Author(s):

It was fairly easy in last week's post to justify looking hard at the costs of care. All I had to do was reference population studies that show wide, unexplainable variation in tests, procedures, the costs, its quality, or benefit (outcomes).

Comparative Effectiveness

It was fairly easy in last week's post to justify looking hard at the costs of care. All I had to do was reference population studies that show wide, unexplainable variation in tests, procedures, the costs, its quality, or benefit (outcomes). The matter resurfaced in an article on comparative effectiveness in the NY Times, May 6, 2009:

"It was in the mid-1990s, when Dr. Deyo [see Hope or Hype: The Obsession with Medical Advances and the High Cost of False Promises] helped develop federal guidelines urging surgeons not to perform spinal fusions to treat acute pain. The reason was simple: There was little evidence that the fusions worked in many patients.

Spine specialists quickly attacked the report, calling it flawed. One medical device maker, Medtronic, sued unsuccessfully to block its release. Republican lawmakers tried to kill the agency that issued the report. It survived, but its funding was drastically cut, and it decided to stop issuing guidelines." And, now we back in the fray as the whole point of comparative effectiveness is resurrected."

Vital to any healthcare reform effort is getting the right care to the right patient at the right time and place, and the obverse—cutting down on inappropriate, unnecessary or unhelpful care or services.

Quoting from "New Effort Reopens a Medical Minefield," we need to "move medical practice beyond the limits of [contrived] trials, by looking at a broader range of evidence that includes the actual experience of patients undergoing treatment." 'Ironically, the motivation for comparative effectiveness is to see what works in practice, rather than overgeneralizing from a few unrepresentative studies.'"

Meier B. "New Effort Reopens a Medical Minefield." NY Times, May 6, 2009

Related Videos
Lauren Collen, MD: Advanced Combination Therapy May Be Effective Option for Pediatric Refractory IBD
Lauren Collen, MD: Some Fragrances May be More Prevalent in Exposomes of Children with Crohn’s Disease
Impact of Long Hospital Stays on Pediatric Gastroparesis Management with Christian Sadaka, MD
Christian Sadaka, MD: Significant Increase in Pediatric Gastroparesis Hospital Admissions After COVID-19
Braden Kuo, MD | Credit: Mass Gen
Akif Shameem, MD: Generalized Anxiety Disorder Linked to Longer Hospitals in Children with IBD
Satish Rao, MD, PhD | Credit: ACG
Monica Kraft, MD: Discussing Phase 3b Findings on Albuterol/Budesonide for Asthma
© 2024 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.